Max and Annie, a married competitive gaming couple, are trying to have children. However, Max is stressed about his inadequacy in comparison to Brooks, his attractive, successful brother. Brooks arrives in Max's Corvette Stingray, Max's dream car, during Max and Annie’s weekend game night. Brooks suggests that he host their next game night in a rental house while he is there. Max and Annie try to hide their games nights from Gary, their awkward neighbor after their divorce.